Put one in the succeed column for Samsung.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit on Friday ruled (PDF) in favor of Samsung in a long-fought patent battle along with Apple
. The court’s ruling means Samsung will certainly not be called for to pay $1twenty million in patent-infringement damages, nor will certainly it have to change any type of product designs, dealing a blow to Apple’s argument that Samsung has actually “slavishly” stolen its intellectual property.
In its ruling, the U.S. Court of Appeals said that Samsung
did not in naked truth violate patents Apple holds related to turning alphanumeric characters, such as phone numbers, in to links, too as the iPhone’s slide-to-unlock feature. The court additionally reversed an earlier jury decision that Samsung violated an Apple patent on auto-correction.
The court was particularly scathing in its comments regarding Apple’s patents, calling them “obvious”—a term used to describe technologies that are not deserving of patents. The court added that Apple’s slide-to-unlock and auto-right patents are “invalid.”
Get Data Sheet, Fortune’s technology newsletter.
Apple and Samsung have actually been battling over patents due to the fact that 2011. The two companies have actually said that the others has actually violated patents they own related to mobile technology and design. As the patent-infringement cases extended across the U.S. and Europe, neither Apple nor Samsung won a considerable case until 2012, as quickly as Apple won a landmark ruling in California that awarded the business a lot more compared to $1 billion in damages.
Since then, the companies decided to scuttle their worldwide disputes and focus solely on the U.S., however the patent-infringement cases have actually continued to fly. Over the last couple of years, a collection of appeals, rulings, and trials whittled down Apple’s $1 billion in damages to $548 million. Samsung has actually appealed that case to the U.S. Ultimate Court in hopes of ultimately dealing a last blow and retrieving its money from Apple, which is currently holding it until the Ultimate Court decides whether to hear the case.
The case in question on Friday is the others big battle between Apple and Samsung. Enjoy the others case, Apple and Samsung sued each others over alleged patent infringement across a slew of mobile devices. Apple had initially sought $2 billion on the patents cited in the case, however was awarded simply $1twenty million by a jury in 2014.
At that time, the jury additionally awarded Samsung over $158,000 for Apple’s alleged infringement of a patent related to the means photos and videos are organized in folders. Interestingly, the U.S. Court of Appeals sided along with the jury on Friday, meaning Samsung will certainly still have the ability to collect that small amount of money if Apple doesn’t appeal the ruling.
Samsung argument in the case centered on the pointer that Apple’s patents are invalid and obvious, and ought to not be a legitimate means by which the business could collect damages. The court’s agreement calls in to question the validity of Apple’s patents and whether the business could (and should) hold patents related to so-called “obvious” technologies Enjoy slide-to-unlock—a software mechanism that allows users to unlock their smartphones.
Given that, it’s feasible the issue could ultimately locate its means to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), which awarded the patents to Apple. The USPTO has actually reviewed the legitimacy and validity of Apple patents in the past, a lot of recently examining whether the so-called ‘915 patent, which describes exactly how the pinch-to-zoom feature functions on touch devices, is “patentable.” The USPTO has actually on divide occasions determined that the ‘915 patent ought to not have actually been awarded, forcing Apple to file an appeal last year to the Federal Circuit in hopes of preserving its patent and the loss associated along with it.
With the current ruling now in, Apple has actually effectively lost $1twenty million in loss it would certainly have actually otherwise received from Samsung and will certainly now have to pay out a little over $158,000. The business can easily either accept the ruling or appeal it, though it hasn’t said exactly what its next relocate will certainly be.
For a lot more on the Apple-Samsung dispute, watch:
An Apple spokesperson declined to comment on the ruling.
In addition to Samsung, several industry giants, including Google
, and eBay
, might be pleased by today’s ruling. In July, those companies, along along with others in the industry, filed a brief along with the Federal Circuit Court supporting Samsung’s fight along with Apple. The companies argued that if Apple’s victories are allowed to stand, it could unleash a collection of subsequent patent lawsuits utilizing the exact same intellectual property to target others device makers. Those lawsuits, the coalition said, would certainly negatively affect the progress of “practical modern technologies” and “have actually a devastating impact on companies.”
Samsung did not respond to a request for comment.